He suggests that if Evan envisions a future with Bree, he should rid himself of the guilt from his past actions. Stephen mentions that Bree might already be aware of the truth and could be waiting for him to come clean.

Meanwhile, Bree confides in Lucy and Pippa about her feelings of being misunderstood by Evan. She shares how the experience of sharing a cigarette with Oliver, despite not being a smoker, felt significant. Bree also describes the emotional impact of Oliver removing the earring from her ear. The girls tease Bree about having a teacher flirt with her. At the same time, Diana arrives at Stephen’s dorm and encounters Wrigley’s tutor, Chloe.

Diana discovers that Wrigley was involved with Chloe and asks him to keep their brief encounter a secret from Stephen to avoid making him uncomfortable.

Meanwhile, Lucy goes on a date with Leo, and they quickly connect. Leo inquires about Stephen and the confession he made in the cafeteria, but Lucy dismisses the topic. As they bond over their shared sense of humor, Leo and Lucy share a kiss.

Back at their house, Evan and Bree attempt to resolve their argument. Evan confesses that he cheated on Bree with another woman, admitting his infidelity. Bree is enraged and accuses Evan of gaslighting her into thinking she was at fault. She also confronts him about his attempt to manipulate her with the expensive earrings.

Bree leaves to process Evan’s confession, and Evan anxiously wonders if she will end their relationship. Meanwhile, Wrigley invites Stephen to join him at a party that night. Stephen inquires about his football team and discovers that Wrigley is no longer practicing with them due to an injury. Feeling sympathetic, Stephen agrees to go out with Wrigley.

Back at the dorm, Lucy returns to find Pippa comforting Bree. She is taken aback to learn about Evan’s confession but is relieved that Lucy’s name wasn’t mentioned. Bree insists that Pippa and Lucy attend the college party while she takes some time alone to reflect on the situation.

At the party, Pippa leaves Leo and Lucy to get a drink and meets a classmate named Quinn, who asks for her number. Meanwhile, Chris arrives and strikes up a conversation with Pippa while Lucy and Leo share a passionate kiss. Bree, feeling distressed, decides to return to the restaurant where she last saw Oliver. She finds him at the bar and takes a seat next to him.

Bree confides in Oliver about having one of the worst days she can remember. Oliver offers to buy her a drink to lift her spirits. Meanwhile, Wrigley and Stephen are at home playing video games, discussing Drew’s attempts to avoid Wrigley. Stephen mentions that Lucy broke his phone during a confrontation but doesn’t explain what caused her anger.

At the party, Lucy observes Pippa and Chris kissing. Back at the restaurant, Bree continues her conversation with Oliver, discussing Evan’s infidelity. Oliver shares some of his own experiences, including how he married his first wife in college and her subsequent death before marrying Marianne. Bree feels sympathy for Oliver and asks if he is happy with Marianne. She flirts with him, but Oliver gently insists that they should not cross any boundaries.

After they leave the restaurant, Oliver plants a kiss on Bree’s cheek. Bree reciprocates, kissing Oliver back on the cheek, and they share a moment. Embarrassed when Oliver tries to stop her, Bree rushes back home and has sex with Evan. Meanwhile, at the party, Diana checks on Pippa, who’s throwing up from excessive drinking. She kicks Chris out of the room and asks Lucy to help with Pippa.

Lucy and Diana attempt to nurse Pippa, trying to get her something to drink. They take Pippa to the dorm room, where Diana confides in Lucy her suspicion that Chris was forcing himself on Pippa. Lucy thanks Diana and puts Pippa to bed. The following morning, Lucy talks to Pippa and discovers she has no memory of hooking up with Chris. When Lucy gently asks if Pippa thinks she might have been drugged, Pippa becomes upset, feeling coddled.